Pair of Clarki Clowns

[Joey P]

I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?

[Charlie Spitzer]

yes. yes.

"Joey P" > wrote in message
om...
> I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
> the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
> grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
> They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
> often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
> say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?

[billi jack]

I was under the impression that a "mated" pair had to have some fry in order
for them to be considered "mated". Am i wrong about this?

"Charlie Spitzer" > wrote in message
...
> yes. yes.
>
> "Joey P" > wrote in message
> om...
> > I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
> > the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
> > grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
> > They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
> > often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
> > say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?
>
>

[Dragon Slayer]

clown fish are born as an "it" and as they mature the more dominate will
become female and the second in line will become a male. the others will
remain it's until the male/female is lost or they move off on their own (in
the ocean anyways). your more dominate (the larger now) became female and
grew to the larger size, the 2nd in line was the only other you had in the
tank and became a male.

so yes its safe to say you now have a matted pair. if you add another to
the tank (if not already matured into male or female) it will be an it until
something happens to one of your existing clowns. if its already developed
into a female (so its seams males can revert to females but not vise versa)
then you will have a fight on hand if your tank isn't quite large enough
with another host for the new addition. if the female is lost by death or
any means, the male will become female and the next in line will become
male.

hth
kc

"Joey P" > wrote in message
om...
> I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
> the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
> grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
> They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
> often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
> say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?

[Dragon Slayer]

having fry is a successfully breeding pair. having a male/female pair
living together in a common host is a mated pair.

kc

"billi jack" > wrote in message
...
> I was under the impression that a "mated" pair had to have some fry in
order
> for them to be considered "mated". Am i wrong about this?
>
> "Charlie Spitzer" > wrote in message
> ...
> > yes. yes.
> >
> > "Joey P" > wrote in message
> > om...
> > > I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
> > > the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
> > > grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
> > > They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
> > > often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
> > > say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?
> >
> >
>
>

[Rastus O'Dingha]

That's actually quite fascinating. At approximately what age will they,
shall we say, develop a gender? Does this phenomenon apply to all species of
clown fish?

--
Rastus O'Dingha
Wainwright AB
"Dragon Slayer" > wrote in message
...
> clown fish are born as an "it" and as they mature the more dominate will
> become female and the second in line will become a male. the others will
> remain it's until the male/female is lost or they move off on their own
(in
> the ocean anyways). your more dominate (the larger now) became female
and
> grew to the larger size, the 2nd in line was the only other you had in the
> tank and became a male.
>
> so yes its safe to say you now have a matted pair. if you add another to
> the tank (if not already matured into male or female) it will be an it
until
> something happens to one of your existing clowns. if its already
developed
> into a female (so its seams males can revert to females but not vise
versa)
> then you will have a fight on hand if your tank isn't quite large enough
> with another host for the new addition. if the female is lost by death or
> any means, the male will become female and the next in line will become
> male.
>
> hth
> kc
>
> "Joey P" > wrote in message
> om...
> > I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
> > the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
> > grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
> > They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
> > often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
> > say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?
>
>

[Dragon Slayer]

from what i have heard/read its all clowns. i think its more a size issue
rather then age, but has to be after XXX amount of age as well.

kc


"Rastus O'Dingha" > wrote in message
news:nZXsb.50036$Ws6.21257@edtnps84...
> That's actually quite fascinating. At approximately what age will they,
> shall we say, develop a gender? Does this phenomenon apply to all species
of
> clown fish?
>
> --
> Rastus O'Dingha
> Wainwright AB
> "Dragon Slayer" > wrote in message
> ...
> > clown fish are born as an "it" and as they mature the more dominate will
> > become female and the second in line will become a male. the others
will
> > remain it's until the male/female is lost or they move off on their own
> (in
> > the ocean anyways). your more dominate (the larger now) became female
> and
> > grew to the larger size, the 2nd in line was the only other you had in
the
> > tank and became a male.
> >
> > so yes its safe to say you now have a matted pair. if you add another
to
> > the tank (if not already matured into male or female) it will be an it
> until
> > something happens to one of your existing clowns. if its already
> developed
> > into a female (so its seams males can revert to females but not vise
> versa)
> > then you will have a fight on hand if your tank isn't quite large enough
> > with another host for the new addition. if the female is lost by death
or
> > any means, the male will become female and the next in line will become
> > male.
> >
> > hth
> > kc
> >
> > "Joey P" > wrote in message
> > om...
> > > I bought 2 of Sri Lanki (sp) clown fish about 3 years ago. At the time
> > > the were both about 1 inch in size. Since then one of the fish has
> > > grown to almost 3 inches. The other has grown to about 1.5 inches.
> > > They are constantly together in an anemone and protect eachother. I
> > > often see them trying to build a nest in the substrate. Is it safe to
> > > say I have a mated pair here?? Is the female the larger of the pair?
> >
> >
>
>

[Richard Reynolds]

> That's actually quite fascinating. At approximately what age will they,
> shall we say, develop a gender? Does this phenomenon apply to all species of
> clown fish?

all clowns start off as it's and change if the environment allows.

the size change is clown specific, a few dont have a great size difference between adult
it's males and females, while others will have huge differences.

the size/age this occurs also is dependant on the clown. id call it safe to consider
anything under 1 year juv and too young to change, but only backed by observation.


--
Richard Reynolds