DO I NEED TO DRAIN POND IN WINTER?

[norraandchris]

This might be a silly question for you seasoned pro's out there, but I just
started learning about ponds and pond maintainance, and put one in my yard
this summer. I've had conflicting advise on draining or not draining in
winter. I live in Omaha Nebraska, generally the winters aren't too cold, but
ocassionally can be sub-zero. My pond at the deepest point is 4 feet. I have
no fish yet, no plants yet. Just a pretty pond and a fountain, with a
plastic liner purchased at The Home Depot........thanks.....

[Simon Avery]

"norraandchris" > wrote:

Hello norraandchris

n> This might be a silly question for you seasoned pro's out
n> there, but I just started learning about ponds and pond
n> maintainance, and put one in my yard
n> this summer. I've had conflicting advise on draining or not
n> draining in winter. I live in Omaha Nebraska, generally the
n> winters aren't too cold, but ocassionally can be sub-zero.
n> My pond at the deepest point is 4 feet. I have no fish yet,
n> no plants yet. Just a pretty pond and a fountain, with
n> a plastic liner purchased at The Home
n> Depot........thanks.....

Why would you drain it? As long as there's 6-12" of free water under
the ice, and there's a hole through it to let gas out, then the fish
will survive.

BTW, plastic does not a good liner make. Butyl is good, polythene
ain't. (Degrades in sunlight, expect it to go brittle around the edges
in 5 years or so - UNLESS you cover the edges right over down and into
the water level)


--
Simon Avery, Dartmoor, UK Ý http://www.digdilem.org/

[Rodney Pont]

On Fri, 08 Aug 2003 22:14:26 GMT, Simon Avery wrote:

>"norraandchris" > wrote:
>
>Hello norraandchris
>
> n> This might be a silly question for you seasoned pro's out
> n> there, but I just started learning about ponds and pond
> n> maintainance, and put one in my yard
> n> this summer. I've had conflicting advise on draining or not
> n> draining in winter. I live in Omaha Nebraska, generally the
> n> winters aren't too cold, but ocassionally can be sub-zero.
> n> My pond at the deepest point is 4 feet. I have no fish yet,
> n> no plants yet. Just a pretty pond and a fountain, with
> n> a plastic liner purchased at The Home
> n> Depot........thanks.....
>
>Why would you drain it? As long as there's 6-12" of free water under
>the ice, and there's a hole through it to let gas out, then the fish
>will survive.
>
>BTW, plastic does not a good liner make. Butyl is good, polythene
>ain't. (Degrades in sunlight, expect it to go brittle around the edges
>in 5 years or so - UNLESS you cover the edges right over down and into
>the water level)

You beat me to this one Simon :-)

Have a quick look at
<http://www.aquatics-online.co.uk/acatalog/Online_Catalogue_Pond_Liners_
__Repair_Kits_and_Tape_23.html>, there's all sorts of things that would
be classed as plastic nowadays.

--
Regards - Rodney Pont
The from address exists but is mostly dumped,
please send any emails to the address below
e-mail ngps07 (at) infohit (dot) fsnet (dot) co (dot) uk

[norraandchris]

Didn't i say I have no fish and no plants?
"Rodney Pont" > wrote in message
.dfn.de...
> On Fri, 08 Aug 2003 15:53:46 GMT, norraandchris wrote:
>
> >This might be a silly question for you seasoned pro's out there, but I
just
> >started learning about ponds and pond maintainance, and put one in my
yard
> >this summer. I've had conflicting advise on draining or not draining in
> >winter. I live in Omaha Nebraska, generally the winters aren't too cold,
but
> >ocassionally can be sub-zero. My pond at the deepest point is 4 feet. I
have
> >no fish yet, no plants yet. Just a pretty pond and a fountain, with a
> >plastic liner purchased at The Home Depot........thanks.....
> >
> I'm in the UK but your description sounds similar to the weather here.
> We don't drain the pond and even leave the waterfall and stream
> running. We may get a half an inch of ice on for two or three days and
> the cat goes ice skating :-)
>
> I'd suggest putting plants in first and then fish. I don't like using a
> planting medium personally since I want the plants to take their
> nutrients from the water so I like them either in gravel in a planter
> or just tied to a big stone. You shouldn't feed the fish in the winter
> when the water temperature is below 10 degrees celcius. With a four
> foot deep pond it's going to be impossible for the pond to freeze to
> any depth if you only have a few days at a time below zero (assuming we
> are talking celcius).
>
> Going back to freezing, if the sides of the pond slant outwards
> slightly to allow the ice to rise as it expands the pond could freeze
> solid without damage. You should try to have some method of keeping a
> hole open so that the fish can get their oxygen and get rid of the
> carbon dioxide. If the outlet from the filter is at or above the
> surface this will be enough. If it's below the surface you can put a
> venturi in and the bubbles will keep it open. Failing that bubbles from
> an air pump will do the same job.
>
> --
> Regards - Rodney Pont
> The from address exists but is mostly dumped,
> please send any emails to the address below
> e-mail ngps07 (at) infohit (dot) fsnet (dot) co (dot) uk
>
>

[Rodney Pont]

On Sun, 10 Aug 2003 00:22:08 GMT, norraandchris wrote:

>Didn't i say I have no fish and no plants?

Yes, but you also said yet so I assumed you would be adding some.

--
Regards - Rodney Pont
The from address exists but is mostly dumped,
please send any emails to the address below
e-mail ngps07 (at) infohit (dot) fsnet (dot) co (dot) uk

[Richard]

"Rodney Pont" > wrote in
.dfn.de:

> On Fri, 08 Aug 2003 15:53:46 GMT, norraandchris wrote:
>
>>This might be a silly question for you seasoned pro's out there, but I
>>just started learning about ponds and pond maintainance, and put one
>>in my yard this summer. I've had conflicting advise on draining or not
>>draining in winter. I live in Omaha Nebraska, generally the winters
>>aren't too cold, but ocassionally can be sub-zero. My pond at the
>>deepest point is 4 feet. I have no fish yet, no plants yet. Just a
>>pretty pond and a fountain, with a plastic liner purchased at The Home
>>Depot........thanks.....
>>
> I'm in the UK but your description sounds similar to the weather here.
> We don't drain the pond and even leave the waterfall and stream
> running. We may get a half an inch of ice on for two or three days and
> the cat goes ice skating :-)
>
> I'd suggest putting plants in first and then fish. I don't like using
> a planting medium personally since I want the plants to take their
> nutrients from the water so I like them either in gravel in a planter
> or just tied to a big stone. You shouldn't feed the fish in the winter
> when the water temperature is below 10 degrees celcius. With a four
> foot deep pond it's going to be impossible for the pond to freeze to
> any depth if you only have a few days at a time below zero (assuming
> we are talking celcius).
>
> Going back to freezing, if the sides of the pond slant outwards
> slightly to allow the ice to rise as it expands the pond could freeze
> solid without damage. You should try to have some method of keeping a
> hole open so that the fish can get their oxygen and get rid of the
> carbon dioxide. If the outlet from the filter is at or above the
> surface this will be enough. If it's below the surface you can put a
> venturi in and the bubbles will keep it open. Failing that bubbles
> from an air pump will do the same job.
>

Hello norraandchris from a fellow midwesterner.
The weather in Nebraska is extreme, temperatures can range from -20F (-
30C) in winter to over 100F (40C) in summer, and it is much drier.

About the pond, is it 'plastic' like they sell for dropcloths, or did you
get a PVC pond liner from Home depot? If it is a pond liner, they are
designed to last for years in the open. If it's just dropcloth platic the
sun will degrade it in a year or two.

As for the water, since you don't have any plants or fish in it yet, you
can either leave the water in or drain it, but if you remove the water
you run the risk of freezing ground pushing in the sides. Once you have
plants and/or fish, you will definitely need to leave the water in. If
you have hardy fish, you can put a bubbler in to keep an open area of
water to let oxygen and carbon dioxide exchange, or even a livestock
water trough heater if the bubbler isn't enough to overcome the weather.

[Jerrispond]

>you run the risk of freezing ground pushing in the sides. Once you have
>plants and/or fish, you will definitely need to leave the water in.

I agree i wouldn't drain it either with or without fish in it.....I don't think
it would be good for ANY kind of liner to be exposed to below freezing
temps.....if it is filled with water it will not get that cold Jerri

http://www.fringeweb.com/Ponds/JerrisPond

[micgalnixon]

I propose to plant, and then fish. I do not like to use Plants grown in one person, because I want to take their nutrients from the water, so I like them both in the rubble of the planter or simply tied to a rock. You should not feed fish in winter when the water temperature below 10 degrees Celsius.