tank cover glass or plexi?

[tyohnk]

I just purchased an established reef tank, that has glass lids on it. I
was
talking to a friend of mine that has a fish only tank and he said that I
deeded plexi glass covers to allow a more natural light spectrum thru. I
remember seeing somthing on this years ago when I had my first tank, but I
thought it was the other way around.
Wich is right glass or plexi?
Thanks

[Benjamin1]

tyohnk,

I think most here will tell you to not use any covers at all on your reef
tank. They generally tend to say:
- It prohibits good gas exchange. *Huge B.S. near as I can find
calculations confirm.*
- It holds heat in. *Get a chiller, and/or have less need for intense light
by keeping cleaner water, and/or run halides less time per day.*
- It prohibits light passage. *have less need for intense light by keeping
cleaner water, and/or run halides less time per day, also tilt the lids so
droplets tend to flow back to the tank instead of hang down, make sure to
keep the tops clean on the outside and the salt creep clear on the inside.*

I'm sure there may be one or more I missed, but for what it's worth I use
the "Solar" glass Oceanic provided and whatever comes on third party tops
you might find in catalogs. I have five tanks so I have a mix of tops.
Some glass has natural or added tint which good acrylic doesn't but I
haven't found it to not matter much either way but that's my opinion not
fact.
Try running for a month with the tops and accumulate the dust that develops
on them. Then ask yourself if that is something you would *feed* your tank
on a regular basis. If it is take the tops off, if not then leave them on
but keep them clean.
You will also be well served to have a filter on your skimmer's air intake
if it is of that type.






tyohnk > wrote in message
...
> I just purchased an established reef tank, that has glass lids on it. I
> was
> talking to a friend of mine that has a fish only tank and he said that I
> deeded plexi glass covers to allow a more natural light spectrum thru. I
> remember seeing somthing on this years ago when I had my first tank, but I
> thought it was the other way around.
> Wich is right glass or plexi?
> Thanks
>
>

[selgado]

Be careful if you have fish that will jump from the water. I've had
good success with flourescent light diffusers to keep fish in. They are
the plastic grids you see on flourescent lights in offices. You can cut
them down to size easily. This allows for gas exchange and heat
dissipation. You can get them at any home depot in the lighting section.

Benjamin1 wrote:
> tyohnk,
>
> I think most here will tell you to not use any covers at all on your reef
> tank. They generally tend to say:
> - It prohibits good gas exchange. *Huge B.S. near as I can find
> calculations confirm.*
> - It holds heat in. *Get a chiller, and/or have less need for intense light
> by keeping cleaner water, and/or run halides less time per day.*
> - It prohibits light passage. *have less need for intense light by keeping
> cleaner water, and/or run halides less time per day, also tilt the lids so
> droplets tend to flow back to the tank instead of hang down, make sure to
> keep the tops clean on the outside and the salt creep clear on the inside.*
>
> I'm sure there may be one or more I missed, but for what it's worth I use
> the "Solar" glass Oceanic provided and whatever comes on third party tops
> you might find in catalogs. I have five tanks so I have a mix of tops.

> Some glass has natural or added tint which good acrylic doesn't but I
> haven't found it to not matter much either way but that's my opinion not
> fact.
> Try running for a month with the tops and accumulate the dust that develops
> on them. Then ask yourself if that is something you would *feed* your tank
> on a regular basis. If it is take the tops off, if not then leave them on
> but keep them clean.
> You will also be well served to have a filter on your skimmer's air intake
> if it is of that type.
>
>
>
>
>
>
> tyohnk > wrote in message
> ...
>
>>I just purchased an established reef tank, that has glass lids on it. I
>>was
>>talking to a friend of mine that has a fish only tank and he said that I
>>deeded plexi glass covers to allow a more natural light spectrum thru. I
>>remember seeing somthing on this years ago when I had my first tank, but I
>>thought it was the other way around.
>>Wich is right glass or plexi?
>>Thanks
>>
>>
>
>
>