View Full Version : Help finding the right fish for new pond
OrSoBoT
July 8th 03, 03:33 AM
I'm building a set of two decorating ponds in my back yard. This is the
setup: Top pond is about 50Gal, water slides down from this pond through a
small waterfall into the bottom pond which is about 120Gal. I want to put
two or more fish on the bottom pond. Things to consider are: the fish have
to control the algae and mosquito population in the pond, they have to be
low maintenance and resilient fish since the ponds are outdoors and
temperatures are quite hot around here. Any recommendations? do Japanese Koi
and plecos get along? can they survive on the same type of water? any other
type of fish that feeds on mosquito larvae (in addition to the supplemental
food I would provide of course).
--
OrSoBoT
Remove "spam" from the e-mail address to reply
Stan
July 9th 03, 12:58 PM
I dought there would be many mesquitoes since they like still, stale, nasty
water with decaying vegetation in it. But, for all the other weird things
that will like your pond....get a few
sunfish....perch....guppies.....swordtails....catf ish......zebra
danios.......whatever......and a turtle...
"OrSoBoT" > wrote in message
...
> I'm building a set of two decorating ponds in my back yard. This is the
> setup: Top pond is about 50Gal, water slides down from this pond through a
> small waterfall into the bottom pond which is about 120Gal. I want to put
> two or more fish on the bottom pond. Things to consider are: the fish have
> to control the algae and mosquito population in the pond, they have to be
> low maintenance and resilient fish since the ponds are outdoors and
> temperatures are quite hot around here. Any recommendations? do Japanese
Koi
> and plecos get along? can they survive on the same type of water? any
other
> type of fish that feeds on mosquito larvae (in addition to the
supplemental
> food I would provide of course).
>
>
> --
> OrSoBoT
> Remove "spam" from the e-mail address to reply
>
>
>
OrSoBoT
July 9th 03, 03:53 PM
Thanks Jim, I think I'll try a couple of plecos and another couple of the
cichlids to see how they like the environment.
"Jim Brown" > wrote in message
.. .
> Plecos should do well. The koi may get too big and the water may be too
> warm for them.
> Presuming the pond will have a black liner, skip black or dark fish.
> Consider albino or gold colours. Platies are one of the first to come to
> mind. If you want one or two bigger fish, any cichlid should be
considered.
> But skip the turtle. They are prone to eat fish, and create a heavy
> bio-load on the pond.
> Enjoy whatever you put in, and don't be afraid to change the fish if your
> interest falls.
>
> Jim
>
> Stan > wrote in message
> ...
> > I dought there would be many mesquitoes since they like still, stale,
> nasty
> > water with decaying vegetation in it. But, for all the other weird
things
> > that will like your pond....get a few
> > sunfish....perch....guppies.....swordtails....catf ish......zebra
> > danios.......whatever......and a turtle...
> >
> > "OrSoBoT" > wrote in message
> > ...
> > > I'm building a set of two decorating ponds in my back yard. This is
the
> > > setup: Top pond is about 50Gal, water slides down from this pond
through
> a
> > > small waterfall into the bottom pond which is about 120Gal. I want to
> put
> > > two or more fish on the bottom pond. Things to consider are: the fish
> have
> > > to control the algae and mosquito population in the pond, they have to
> be
> > > low maintenance and resilient fish since the ponds are outdoors and
> > > temperatures are quite hot around here. Any recommendations? do
Japanese
> > Koi
> > > and plecos get along? can they survive on the same type of water? any
> > other
> > > type of fish that feeds on mosquito larvae (in addition to the
> > supplemental
> > > food I would provide of course).
> > >
> > >
> > > --
> > > OrSoBoT
> > > Remove "spam" from the e-mail address to reply
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
Justin Grantham
July 9th 03, 06:32 PM
if you do have a mosquito problem, there should probably get mosquito fish
in it. If you live in the us near a river they can be found near the slow
moving parts of it. Some lfs even carry them.
"OrSoBoT" > wrote in message
...
> Thanks Jim, I think I'll try a couple of plecos and another couple of the
> cichlids to see how they like the environment.
>
> "Jim Brown" > wrote in message
> .. .
> > Plecos should do well. The koi may get too big and the water may be too
> > warm for them.
> > Presuming the pond will have a black liner, skip black or dark fish.
> > Consider albino or gold colours. Platies are one of the first to come
to
> > mind. If you want one or two bigger fish, any cichlid should be
> considered.
> > But skip the turtle. They are prone to eat fish, and create a heavy
> > bio-load on the pond.
> > Enjoy whatever you put in, and don't be afraid to change the fish if
your
> > interest falls.
> >
> > Jim
> >
> > Stan > wrote in message
> > ...
> > > I dought there would be many mesquitoes since they like still, stale,
> > nasty
> > > water with decaying vegetation in it. But, for all the other weird
> things
> > > that will like your pond....get a few
> > > sunfish....perch....guppies.....swordtails....catf ish......zebra
> > > danios.......whatever......and a turtle...
> > >
> > > "OrSoBoT" > wrote in message
> > > ...
> > > > I'm building a set of two decorating ponds in my back yard. This is
> the
> > > > setup: Top pond is about 50Gal, water slides down from this pond
> through
> > a
> > > > small waterfall into the bottom pond which is about 120Gal. I want
to
> > put
> > > > two or more fish on the bottom pond. Things to consider are: the
fish
> > have
> > > > to control the algae and mosquito population in the pond, they have
to
> > be
> > > > low maintenance and resilient fish since the ponds are outdoors and
> > > > temperatures are quite hot around here. Any recommendations? do
> Japanese
> > > Koi
> > > > and plecos get along? can they survive on the same type of water?
any
> > > other
> > > > type of fish that feeds on mosquito larvae (in addition to the
> > > supplemental
> > > > food I would provide of course).
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > --
> > > > OrSoBoT
> > > > Remove "spam" from the e-mail address to reply
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
>
Cichlidiot
July 9th 03, 08:44 PM
In alt.aquaria Justin Grantham > wrote:
> if you do have a mosquito problem, there should probably get mosquito fish
> in it. If you live in the us near a river they can be found near the slow
> moving parts of it. Some lfs even carry them.
If you live in the USA, do not take your mosquito fish from the river. You
could introduce all sorts of pathogens into your pond that way. Also,
depending on where you live, it might even be illegal to do so. Instead
call the local mosquito abatement/control department (look them up in the
phone book). They're likely the ones that introduced the fish to the river
in the first place. Last I checked, most mosquito abatement agencies
provide mosquito fish for either free or a very modest sum for backyard
water features like ponds. The fish you've seen in the pet store are
probably wild guppies. While these are related to the mosquito fish (and
will interbreed), I believe the mosquito fish is a bit more voracious when
it comes to eating mosquito larva.
Now as for what the original poster could put in the pond, it is a bit
small for koi. A couple of goldfish might work instead, but, take the pond
temperature at both the surface and bottom if possible on a hot day. If
it's over 75-80F even at the bottom, goldfish should be ruled out as well.
Also, consider the winter temps. If you put in tropicals to survive the
summer heat, you may need a tank inside the house to hold them over winter
if the winter temps get too cold.
OrSoBoT
July 10th 03, 05:54 AM
Uhmmm.... here in South Florida we do have a BIG mosquito problem, but we
learned to live with it ;o)
There are lots of canals around this area, but I really don't want to take
any fish from these canals, I rather get them from the LFS. I've heard these
fish can carry some diseases that would kill the other fish in the pond.
I'll go check my LFS this weekend, thanks for the tip.
"Justin Grantham" > wrote in message
news:flYOa.18353$Ph3.1315@sccrnsc04...
> if you do have a mosquito problem, there should probably get mosquito fish
> in it. If you live in the us near a river they can be found near the slow
> moving parts of it. Some lfs even carry them.
>
>
> "OrSoBoT" > wrote in message
> ...
> > Thanks Jim, I think I'll try a couple of plecos and another couple of
the
> > cichlids to see how they like the environment.
> >
> > "Jim Brown" > wrote in message
> > .. .
> > > Plecos should do well. The koi may get too big and the water may be
too
> > > warm for them.
> > > Presuming the pond will have a black liner, skip black or dark fish.
> > > Consider albino or gold colours. Platies are one of the first to come
> to
> > > mind. If you want one or two bigger fish, any cichlid should be
> > considered.
> > > But skip the turtle. They are prone to eat fish, and create a heavy
> > > bio-load on the pond.
> > > Enjoy whatever you put in, and don't be afraid to change the fish if
> your
> > > interest falls.
> > >
> > > Jim
> > >
> > > Stan > wrote in message
> > > ...
> > > > I dought there would be many mesquitoes since they like still,
stale,
> > > nasty
> > > > water with decaying vegetation in it. But, for all the other weird
> > things
> > > > that will like your pond....get a few
> > > > sunfish....perch....guppies.....swordtails....catf ish......zebra
> > > > danios.......whatever......and a turtle...
> > > >
> > > > "OrSoBoT" > wrote in message
> > > > ...
> > > > > I'm building a set of two decorating ponds in my back yard. This
is
> > the
> > > > > setup: Top pond is about 50Gal, water slides down from this pond
> > through
> > > a
> > > > > small waterfall into the bottom pond which is about 120Gal. I want
> to
> > > put
> > > > > two or more fish on the bottom pond. Things to consider are: the
> fish
> > > have
> > > > > to control the algae and mosquito population in the pond, they
have
> to
> > > be
> > > > > low maintenance and resilient fish since the ponds are outdoors
and
> > > > > temperatures are quite hot around here. Any recommendations? do
> > Japanese
> > > > Koi
> > > > > and plecos get along? can they survive on the same type of water?
> any
> > > > other
> > > > > type of fish that feeds on mosquito larvae (in addition to the
> > > > supplemental
> > > > > food I would provide of course).
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > > --
> > > > > OrSoBoT
> > > > > Remove "spam" from the e-mail address to reply
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
> >
>
>
OrSoBoT
July 10th 03, 06:01 AM
Thanks for the info on the mosquito fish. The temp on the ponds will be on
the mid 80's all year long. For the very few days that the temp drops below
70 here on S. Fla., I can arrange to put the fish in one of my indoor tanks.
"Cichlidiot" > wrote in message
...
> In alt.aquaria Justin Grantham > wrote:
> > if you do have a mosquito problem, there should probably get mosquito
fish
> > in it. If you live in the us near a river they can be found near the
slow
> > moving parts of it. Some lfs even carry them.
>
> If you live in the USA, do not take your mosquito fish from the river. You
> could introduce all sorts of pathogens into your pond that way. Also,
> depending on where you live, it might even be illegal to do so. Instead
> call the local mosquito abatement/control department (look them up in the
> phone book). They're likely the ones that introduced the fish to the river
> in the first place. Last I checked, most mosquito abatement agencies
> provide mosquito fish for either free or a very modest sum for backyard
> water features like ponds. The fish you've seen in the pet store are
> probably wild guppies. While these are related to the mosquito fish (and
> will interbreed), I believe the mosquito fish is a bit more voracious when
> it comes to eating mosquito larva.
>
> Now as for what the original poster could put in the pond, it is a bit
> small for koi. A couple of goldfish might work instead, but, take the pond
> temperature at both the surface and bottom if possible on a hot day. If
> it's over 75-80F even at the bottom, goldfish should be ruled out as well.
> Also, consider the winter temps. If you put in tropicals to survive the
> summer heat, you may need a tank inside the house to hold them over winter
> if the winter temps get too cold.
vBulletin® v3.6.4, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.