Dead Snails

[Bill Stock]

I've got two snails on the bottom of the tank that lost most of the colour
in their shells. I don't know if they were sucked out of their shells by
someone or if they died from a lack of minerals? Is the loss of colour an
indication of a mineral problem or would they lose their colour after dying
anyway? I suppose the Excel might have done them in too, but the other
smaller snails seem OK. (So far).


TIA

[Altum]

Bill Stock wrote:
> I've got two snails on the bottom of the tank that lost most of the colour
> in their shells. I don't know if they were sucked out of their shells by
> someone or if they died from a lack of minerals? Is the loss of colour an
> indication of a mineral problem or would they lose their colour after dying
> anyway? I suppose the Excel might have done them in too, but the other
> smaller snails seem OK. (So far).

Excel kills snails??? Is that why I have such problems with mystery
snails taking strolls out of the tank? My ramshorns seem fine but that
would explain a lot.

My ramshorn snails get light stripes on their shells if they run low on
minerals.

--
Put the word aquaria in the subject to email me.
Did you read the FAQ? http://faq.thekrib.com

[Koi-Lo]

"Bill Stock" > wrote in message
...
> I've got two snails on the bottom of the tank that lost most of the colour
> in their shells. I don't know if they were sucked out of their shells by
> someone or if they died from a lack of minerals? Is the loss of colour an
> indication of a mineral problem or would they lose their colour after
> dying anyway? I suppose the Excel might have done them in too, but the
> other smaller snails seem OK. (So far).
==========================
My mystery snail seemed to do ok for a few weeks, then I found it's empty
shell behind a slate decoration. The much smaller pond-snails are fine. I
also use Excel. Does it kill mystery snails?
--
Koi-Lo....
Aquariums since 1952.
My Pond & Aquarium Pages:
http://tinyurl.com/9do58
~~~~ }<((((*> ~~~ }<{{{{(ö> ~~~~ }<((((({*>

[Bill Stock]

"Altum" > wrote in message
. net...
> Bill Stock wrote:
>> I've got two snails on the bottom of the tank that lost most of the
>> colour in their shells. I don't know if they were sucked out of their
>> shells by someone or if they died from a lack of minerals? Is the loss of
>> colour an indication of a mineral problem or would they lose their colour
>> after dying anyway? I suppose the Excel might have done them in too, but
>> the other smaller snails seem OK. (So far).
>
> Excel kills snails??? Is that why I have such problems with mystery
> snails taking strolls out of the tank? My ramshorns seem fine but that
> would explain a lot.
>
> My ramshorn snails get light stripes on their shells if they run low on
> minerals.

I thought I remembered a post by Elaine talking about Snails and Excel, but
a search did not find it. But I did see a couple of posts by Richard stating
that it would NOT harm Snails. So I guess I'll have to drag out the KH/GH
test kits tomorrow. Failing that, I'll form a line up and ask the remaining
Snails to identify the guilty party. Likely a Cherry Barb, as the SAEs have
never shown much interest in the non-veg food.

[Bill Stock]

"Koi-Lo" > wrote in message
...
>
> "Bill Stock" > wrote in message
> ...
>> I've got two snails on the bottom of the tank that lost most of the
>> colour in their shells. I don't know if they were sucked out of their
>> shells by someone or if they died from a lack of minerals? Is the loss of
>> colour an indication of a mineral problem or would they lose their colour
>> after dying anyway? I suppose the Excel might have done them in too, but
>> the other smaller snails seem OK. (So far).
> ==========================
> My mystery snail seemed to do ok for a few weeks, then I found it's empty
> shell behind a slate decoration. The much smaller pond-snails are fine.
> I also use Excel. Does it kill mystery snails?

I don't think so, based on a quick search. Before I start any nasty rumours.
Mine are just plain old Pond Snails, but sunce their numbers are in check I
don't mind them. I'll check the PH, etc. tomorrow.

[Frank]

Bill Stock wrote,
>I thought I remembered a post by Elaine ...........

Me too, quite a few of them for awhile, then nothing - where did she
go? ............. Frank

[Mister Gardener]

On Sat, 6 May 2006 23:17:50 -0400, "Bill Stock" >
wrote:

>
>"Altum" > wrote in message
. net...
>> Bill Stock wrote:
>>> I've got two snails on the bottom of the tank that lost most of the
>>> colour in their shells. I don't know if they were sucked out of their
>>> shells by someone or if they died from a lack of minerals? Is the loss of
>>> colour an indication of a mineral problem or would they lose their colour
>>> after dying anyway? I suppose the Excel might have done them in too, but
>>> the other smaller snails seem OK. (So far).
>>
>> Excel kills snails??? Is that why I have such problems with mystery
>> snails taking strolls out of the tank? My ramshorns seem fine but that
>> would explain a lot.
>>
>> My ramshorn snails get light stripes on their shells if they run low on
>> minerals.
>
>I thought I remembered a post by Elaine talking about Snails and Excel, but
>a search did not find it. But I did see a couple of posts by Richard stating
>that it would NOT harm Snails. So I guess I'll have to drag out the KH/GH
>test kits tomorrow. Failing that, I'll form a line up and ask the remaining
>Snails to identify the guilty party. Likely a Cherry Barb, as the SAEs have
>never shown much interest in the non-veg food.
>
Excel killing snails. That's a new one on me, and wouldn't it be nice.
Maybe Elaine's messages on this are lurking in the archives, just
waiting for an adept searcher. Meanwhile, Missus Gardener has a step
stool in front of the big planted tank and she does an Excel-lent job
of crushing every snail she finds. Especially those tiny pond snails
that ride in on new plants. My plant damage has decreased dramatically
in recent weeks, but that may simply be a result of Missus Gardener's
diligence.

-- Mister Gardener
-- Pull the WEED to email me

[Bill Stock]

"Frank" > wrote in message
oups.com...
> Bill Stock wrote,
>>I thought I remembered a post by Elaine ...........
>
> Me too, quite a few of them for awhile, then nothing - where did she
> go? ............. Frank

I haven't seen NM much lately either. Hmmmm..... :)