CO-2 injection into a canister filter.

[Triffid Farmer]

I've set up a Yeast CO-2 system and have been toying with different ways of
diffusing the gas into the tank.
Last night I hooked the CO-2 line directly into the inlet of my canister
filter.
I was going to set up a powerhead and airstone as per a couple of websites
but thought that the canister filter method would do a better job.

It seems to totally pulverise the bubbles into the water and still run
silently.
I can't see any gas bubbles coming out the submerged filter spray bar so I'm
assuming that it's totally dilluting the gas.
As the filter is a totally closed system I also can't see anyway that the
gas could not be injected into the water.

Has anyone tried this method and or am I barking up the wrong tree?

[Graham Ramsay]

That's how I, and many others, do it.
I do get some bubbles out the other end though.

--
Graham Ramsay
Learn about the work of the JREF
www.randi.org

"Triffid Farmer" wrote in
> I've set up a Yeast CO-2 system and have been toying with different ways of
> diffusing the gas into the tank.
> Last night I hooked the CO-2 line directly into the inlet of my canister
> filter.

> Has anyone tried this method and or am I barking up the wrong tree?

[Rick]

"Triffid Farmer" > wrote in message
...
> I've set up a Yeast CO-2 system and have been toying with different ways
of
> diffusing the gas into the tank.
> Last night I hooked the CO-2 line directly into the inlet of my canister
> filter.
> I was going to set up a powerhead and airstone as per a couple of websites
> but thought that the canister filter method would do a better job.
>
> It seems to totally pulverise the bubbles into the water and still run
> silently.
> I can't see any gas bubbles coming out the submerged filter spray bar so
I'm
> assuming that it's totally dilluting the gas.
> As the filter is a totally closed system I also can't see anyway that the
> gas could not be injected into the water.
>
> Has anyone tried this method and or am I barking up the wrong tree?
>
>
>
I run my CO2 line into the intake of my Fluval 404 and it works very well. I
use a pressurized system and do get purges of bubbles every now and again.
It depends on how dirty the media in my Fluval is as to the frequently of
the purging.

Rick

[Dave M. Picklyk]

Hi Triffid. I run the C02 directly into my intake pipes of my aquaclear
filter with no problems at all! Usually some C02 will be lost with the
tumultuous way the water is put back into the tank whether it's a waterfall
effect or a power head. Even with that downfall I usually get around 25 to
30ppm of C02 consistantly with DIY.

Dave.

"Triffid Farmer" > wrote in message
...
> I've set up a Yeast CO-2 system and have been toying with different ways
of
> diffusing the gas into the tank.
> Last night I hooked the CO-2 line directly into the inlet of my canister
> filter.
> I was going to set up a powerhead and airstone as per a couple of websites
> but thought that the canister filter method would do a better job.
>
> It seems to totally pulverise the bubbles into the water and still run
> silently.
> I can't see any gas bubbles coming out the submerged filter spray bar so
I'm
> assuming that it's totally dilluting the gas.
> As the filter is a totally closed system I also can't see anyway that the
> gas could not be injected into the water.
>
> Has anyone tried this method and or am I barking up the wrong tree?
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>

[Dave]

I used to inject CO2 into my canister filter, but now use a Hagen
Natural Plant System diffuser. Hides easily behind some background
plants, no maintenance, works great in my heavily-planted 29g tank. I
can't say whether it would be adequate for larger tanks.

[Rick]

"Dave" > wrote in message
om...
> I used to inject CO2 into my canister filter, but now use a Hagen
> Natural Plant System diffuser. Hides easily behind some background
> plants, no maintenance, works great in my heavily-planted 29g tank. I
> can't say whether it would be adequate for larger tanks.


one of these units I believe is recommended for up to 20 g tank so for
larger tanks you would need multiple units. Lots of people simply buy the
diffusers and use DIY solutions.

Rick

[Squid]

On 9 May 2004 07:19:25 -0700, (Dave) wrote:

>I used to inject CO2 into my canister filter, but now use a Hagen
>Natural Plant System diffuser. Hides easily behind some background
>plants, no maintenance, works great in my heavily-planted 29g tank. I
>can't say whether it would be adequate for larger tanks.

Does yours emit the order from the container? Recently after I changed
the container I noticed that the odor is starting to be released from
the hose. I changed the hose out with some extra I had from the kit
and made sure the cap was on tight. It didn't smell for a couple of
days but now it's starting to stink up again. It's not that annoying
if I have to live with it; I just never noticed the smell during the
first few months. Could the weather have anything to do with it - it's
been pretty hot down here - 90 - 100's

[Dave]

"Rick" > wrote in message >...
> "Dave" > wrote in message
> om...
> > I used to inject CO2 into my canister filter, but now use a Hagen
> > Natural Plant System diffuser. Hides easily behind some background
> > plants, no maintenance, works great in my heavily-planted 29g tank. I
> > can't say whether it would be adequate for larger tanks.
>
>
> one of these units I believe is recommended for up to 20 g tank so for
> larger tanks you would need multiple units. Lots of people simply buy the
> diffusers and use DIY solutions.

Yes, that's what I do. I use two 2-quart juice bottles with the
tubing connected to a "T", and change one out about every 3 weeks.
The diffuser does a great job.

[Dave]

"Squid" > wrote in message
...
> On 9 May 2004 07:19:25 -0700, (Dave) wrote:
>
> >I used to inject CO2 into my canister filter, but now use a Hagen
> >Natural Plant System diffuser. Hides easily behind some background
> >plants, no maintenance, works great in my heavily-planted 29g tank. I
> >can't say whether it would be adequate for larger tanks.
>
> Does yours emit the order from the container?

I only use the diffuser, not the entire system.