Absolutely right Sandy, and thanks for posting those links. I am a BGA
survivor :o
so I know what this stuff can do, it literally took over my tank and
covered EVERYTHING. Anyway, adding NO3 and PO4 in the correct relation
sorted the problem for me, but you're absolutely right, try everything until
something works, all our tanks are different so one of these methods should
work. Cheers for now.
--
**So long, and thanks for all the fish!**

"Sandy Birrell" wrote in message
. ..
Happy'Cam'per wrote:
********.
Sandy, everything you said was true except for the anti-bacterial
agent. It can be erradicted using good husbandry (water quality) and
adding nutrients back that are missing, most notably NO3 and PO4. Try
it and see!



I don't have it anymore. I used to have it in both tanks till I got two
Plecs., now it is no more :)

The below was taken from here.

http://saltaquarium.about.com/od/aboutphosphatepo4/

"Phosphate or PO4 is a prime food source of algae, particularly
cyanobacteria or slime forms."

I also found this which backs up your method.

http://www.xs4all.nl/~buddendo/aquar...dfield_eng.htm

This is worth a read.

http://www.thekrib.com/Plants/Algae/cyanobacteria.html

It seems we should try evrything and see what works for us :)

--


Don`t Worry, Be Happy

Sandy
--

E-Mail:-
Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk
Looking for a webhost? Try http://www.1and1.co.uk/?k_id=2966019

this is getting confusing, I have read and been told that blackouts kill the
bacteria because it needs light to live and that a two to four day blackout
should kill all the bacteria in an aquarium. are you saying that blackouts
cannot work?
"Sandy Birrell" wrote in message
. ..
Scott wrote:
doesn't it have to get into the tank on plants or from water that
fish come in?

It is everywhere, it has even been found thousands of feet up in the
atmosphere. It is a bacteria, you can dry it out and years later add water
and it will grow. It doesn't need light to live and it can process the
nitrogen in the air to feed. The only way to realy kill it is to use an
anti-bacterial agent.

HTH.


--


Don`t Worry, Be Happy

Sandy
--

E-Mail:-
Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk
Looking for a webhost? Try http://www.1and1.co.uk/?k_id=2966019

Scott wrote:
this is getting confusing, I have read and been told that blackouts
kill the bacteria because it needs light to live and that a two to
four day blackout should kill all the bacteria in an aquarium. are
you saying that blackouts cannot work?

The blackouts will kill the chlorophil in the bacteria, but not the bacteria
itself. Once this is done you then have to make sure all your water
parameters are right, and keep them that way, or it will just come back
again. To get rid of it completely you have to kill the bacteria.

Read the rest of this thread, you will find there are more ways to deal with
this than you will have time to try :)


--


Don`t Worry, Be Happy

Sandy
--

E-Mail:-
Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk
Looking for a webhost? Try http://www.1and1.co.uk/?k_id=2966019

"Aquarijen" wrote in message ...
Why go to all that trouble and cost when you can blackout of the tank
for 3 days and cost you nothing and is 100% effective at killing it?

Not sure why people suggest drugs vs something that is FREE and
effective.

Do 50% water change, add 1/4 teaspoon of KNO3 per 20 gal.
Cover with trash bag towels etc so that no light gets in for 3 full
days.
Remove CO2, increase water movement.

Do 50% water change and add the KNO3 back and make sure you dose
enough KNO3 for the tank take care of the tank regularly from then on
with dosing and water changes.

You need to put this method in your web site and detail it out, not
antibiotics.
It's Free
It's faster
It addresses the long term problem, (poor plant growth)
It's simpler and not everyone has access to antibiotics.
It's 100% effective also.
It's been done many many times all over the world.

Regards,
Tom Barr


The OP said that he did blackouts several times and the algae came back.
-Jen

He did not add the KNO3 back and has run low on NO3.
It's that simple.

When the plants grow well, the algae does not, there is a reason for
the plants not growing well, generally with BGA, low is the primary
cause for blooms.

I've done this and have trace psores of BGA in my tank, we all do.
Every sample I've ever looked at under the scope has had Oscillitoria
which is the geneus we have in our tanks.

I can lead you to water but if you do not follow the advice, I cannot
help and I suggested a solution, whether someone choses to do it, it
completely out of my hands but the method does work if you follow it.



Regards,
Tom Barr

BINGO...

No light will temporarily eliminate it, but it will come back if you haven't
changed the reason you got it in the first place (water parameters).

--
Craig Brye
University of Phoenix Online

"Sandy Birrell" wrote in message
. ..
Scott wrote:
this is getting confusing, I have read and been told that blackouts
kill the bacteria because it needs light to live and that a two to
four day blackout should kill all the bacteria in an aquarium. are
you saying that blackouts cannot work?

The blackouts will kill the chlorophil in the bacteria, but not the
bacteria
itself. Once this is done you then have to make sure all your water
parameters are right, and keep them that way, or it will just come back
again. To get rid of it completely you have to kill the bacteria.

Read the rest of this thread, you will find there are more ways to deal
with
this than you will have time to try :)


--


Don`t Worry, Be Happy

Sandy
--

E-Mail:-
Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk
Looking for a webhost? Try http://www.1and1.co.uk/?k_id=2966019

"Sandy Birrell" wrote in message ...
Scott wrote:
doesn't it have to get into the tank on plants or from water that
fish come in?

It is everywhere, it has even been found thousands of feet up in the
atmosphere. It is a bacteria, you can dry it out and years later add water
and it will grow. It doesn't need light to live and it can process the
nitrogen in the air to feed. The only way to realy kill it is to use an
anti-bacterial agent.

HTH.


No, this is not true. This tgenus is Oscillitoria, they don't use N2
gas unless they have heterocyst, no heterocyst, no N2 fixing.
You have generalized an entire group here and the species that infest
our tanks is a particular species.

You can kill it with antibiotics but then the air born spores land and
20-30 days later you can get it again. Mt St Helens had it after 20
days after the blast in 1980. Fire ecology finds these genus appearing
20-30 days an intense fire.

And it does in fact need light to live and grow. The spores are very
resistant, but the tank you have has is in there, it's waiting for the
right conditions to grow.

That's why I suggest adding KNO3, generally, low N levels cause it to
occur with poor plant growth stunted from a lack of N.

The BGA is NOT N limited in the least, you don't have a test kit that
can measure the needs and limits of BGA.

Well unless you work at research lab specifically on water quality
parameters and can speciate BGA's.
I do and can.

Regards,
Tom Barr

"Craig Brye" wrote in message ...
BINGO...

No light will temporarily eliminate it, but it will come back if you haven't
changed the reason you got it in the first place (water parameters).

--
Craig Brye
University of Phoenix Online

"Sandy Birrell" wrote in message
. ..
Scott wrote:
this is getting confusing, I have read and been told that blackouts
kill the bacteria because it needs light to live and that a two to
four day blackout should kill all the bacteria in an aquarium. are
you saying that blackouts cannot work?

The blackouts will kill the chlorophil in the bacteria, but not the
bacteria
itself. Once this is done you then have to make sure all your water
parameters are right, and keep them that way, or it will just come back
again. To get rid of it completely you have to kill the bacteria.

Read the rest of this thread, you will find there are more ways to deal
with
this than you will have time to try :)


--


Don`t Worry, Be Happy

Sandy
--

E-Mail:-
Website:- http://www.ftscotland.co.uk
Looking for a webhost? Try http://www.1and1.co.uk/?k_id=2966019



And that's why I said kill it first, then add the KNO3 thereafter.
You need to remove or kill(cause senscence) whatever is there, THEN
correct the issue which was poor plant growth(NO3 limited plants).

This is true for any algae/plant combo. Remove the algae/kill it etc,
then correct the plant growth problem.

Even if you managed to kill it all with drugs, 30 days later you'll
have air born in your tank again unless you practice sterile technique
and have the tank sealed/filtered air etc.

Regards,
Tom Barr