NetMax wrote:

snip


I think the bottom line with many of us, is that we like to tinker. We
walk by the tank, and make a note to do something, or just do it (move a
rock, clean some algae, feed the fish, replant something, pull some dead
leaves out, watch some new behaviour, check how the fry are doing etc
etc). The suggested scenario took away your ability to tinker.

Let me give an analogy. What you suggest is rather like putting a few
dogs into a big, grassy field with some cameras. (Assume their needs
for shelter and running room are met.) You would feed and water them
daily and clean up as necessary, but that would be the extent of the
interaction. On your living room wall would be a projection of the dogs
so you can see them play, sleep and hang out. The dogs would be
perfectly fine and your chores would be lighter, but the setup is not
the same as having a pet dog at your feet.

I think most of us think of our fish as pets. You've mentioned feeding
your fish with automatic feeders so you see more of the natural
behavior. In contrast, I enjoy watching my angel fish doing his little
"wiggle dance" at the front of the tank when I come into the room. All
he's after is a handout, but the interaction is still fun. Think of how
popular Oscars are because of their pet-like qualities!

--
Elaine T __
http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__
rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com