"Mark Earnest" wrote in message
...

"Uncle Vic" wrote in message
...
One fine day in alt.atheism, "Mark Earnest"
bloodied us up with this:


"Uncle Vic" wrote in message
...
One fine day in alt.atheism, "Mark Earnest"
bloodied us up with this:

God is not redefined. He has always been things atheist believe
in, like light, intelligence, compassion, and perfection.

None of which are 'god'.

Yes they are, and you know it.

Why on earth would an atheist know that your references are evidence
of "god" when said atheist does not believe in *any* gods, including
yours?

We know what produces light, it is not supernatural.
We know what produces intelligence, it is not supernatural.
We know what produces compassion, it is not supernatural.
Perfection is a pipe dream of those who believe in the supernatural.

Yes, it is not supernatural, but it is qualities of God, which
atheists believe in.


These "qualities of god" are of your own invention, and they usually
correspond to the qualities of common sense, which require no gods.

How can perfect virtues not be qualities of the infinite?

Define "perfect virtue".

Show how light, intelligence, and compassion satisfy that definition.

Define "infinite" in terms that require that light, intelligence, and
compassion are qualities of it.