Hi,
"San Diego Joe" wrote in message
...
"JGW" wrote:
Specifically, we are wondering about:
1. pond kits vs. buying the separate components individually

Almost always individually, IMHO.
snip

What SJD said.

2. Preformed pond liners vs. flexible pond liners

For anything larger, flexible liner without question. Actually, now that I
think about it, it would be easier for a small pond too. You have to dig
the
hole the same, but for the preform it has to be leveled, etc. The liner
just
gets put in, albeit you would want to use an underlayment.

Flexible almost always because the shape is variable and most important the
depth can be deeper than most preforms. Also the angle of the sides can
usually be more verticle with flex liner. But flex liner has to be level
also, personally I'd consider a concrete rim with liner over it.

3. Recommended sources for materials

I bought some of my stuff from:
http://www.justliners.com
&
http://www.pumpworld.net

Never bought from either of these sites but the justliners site has a link
to books that could be useful to you. Basically if Helen Nash wrote it you
can't go far wrong. Her "The Complete Pond Builder" is a good start.

4. Recommended sources for instructions on how to do this?
You are at the best source - this news group. snip

SDJ is right again - rec.ponds

5. The pros and cons of putting river rock in the bottom of the pond.

Pros: Looks way, way, way better.
Cons: Cleaning is a PITA

Here SDJ goes wrong but he is entitled to his opinion even if he is wrong.
Did I tell you he is wrong on this.
I'm an ex stoner -- recovering ;-)
HTH -_- how
no NEWS is good