How to get rid of Aptasia outbreak

I have a major outbreak of Aptasia in my tank and know with time it
will damage my coral. I have heard of all types of ways to get rid of
them such as getting peppermint shrimp, getting a syringe with needle
and use it to squirt vinegar into them and as well buying solutions
that you can insert with the syringe. I have tried the latter but
unfortunately when I get close to them they close up so I am not able
to do this. As well, I heard if you break them apart they multiply.
Any suggestions on how I can solve this problem?

I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well as
that section of live rock.

b

--
¼á
"MarkW" wrote in message
...
I have a major outbreak of Aptasia in my tank and know with time it
will damage my coral. I have heard of all types of ways to get rid
of
them such as getting peppermint shrimp, getting a syringe with
needle
and use it to squirt vinegar into them and as well buying solutions
that you can insert with the syringe. I have tried the latter but
unfortunately when I get close to them they close up so I am not
able
to do this. As well, I heard if you break them apart they
multiply.
Any suggestions on how I can solve this problem?

Theres a product I use called Joe's Juice which I have used and it does
work ! Its also supposed to be reef safe and I've never had any trouble
with it. You don't need to inject, you just dribble the stuff over it to
eat and they just dissapear. Great stuff.



"Billy" wrote in
news
I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well as
that section of live rock.

b

YOu can get the same results with lemon juice, or if your paranoid
about injecting the stalk with lemon juice (all it takes is a tiny
drop) so ph etc is not affected. Use a syringe of kalkwasser, and just
squirt the aipstasia with it, no need to inject....I have used lemon
juice with excellent results. Unless you have a true peppermint shrimp
its not likely that the shrimp will eat it. Peppermints (wunderman or
something like that) will eat the aip, if they are hungry, but if
suitable feed is found it is unlikely it will touch it. Copperbanded
butterflys eat it but then yu have another added fish to the bio load
to contend with....

Personally I like aip, and have a 0 gal tanbk setup with nothing but
all the undesireable types normally removed from an aquarium and
flushed or destroyed. Its amaziing and is just as interesting to look
at as a fully stocked reef tank is.......Aip that I have is beautiful,
easy to keep, and its also in various colors. I especially like the
extremely brilliant florescent yellow / green aip....Its just as
pretty as any high end anenome you r going to buy. And to tell the
truth, having it propagate and grow rampantly in this tank has not
been any kind of problem.........

JOes juice is high priced IMHO, but it works, but so does lemon juice,
or kalkwasser which is a lot cheaper.

On Thu, 02 Mar 2006 03:11:52 -0600, Martin
wrote:
Theres a product I use called Joe's Juice which I have used and it does
work ! Its also supposed to be reef safe and I've never had any trouble
with it. You don't need to inject, you just dribble the stuff over it to
eat and they just dissapear. Great stuff.



"Billy" wrote in
news46dnRGmfvdlCJvZnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@comcast. com:

I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well as
that section of live rock.

b


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....

Roy wrote:
Copperbanded
butterflys eat it but then yu have another added fish to the bio load
to contend with....

Butterflies also eat other things, some of which you might not want eaten. I've
read that they are not considered to be "reef safe."

George Patterson
Coffee is only a way of stealing time that should by rights belong to
your slightly older self.

Roy, just how are u gettin them safely off the rock into ur Aip tank?

Do you have any pics of this tank - i would love to see it


"Roy" wrote in message
...
YOu can get the same results with lemon juice, or if your paranoid
about injecting the stalk with lemon juice (all it takes is a tiny
drop) so ph etc is not affected. Use a syringe of kalkwasser, and just
squirt the aipstasia with it, no need to inject....I have used lemon
juice with excellent results. Unless you have a true peppermint shrimp
its not likely that the shrimp will eat it. Peppermints (wunderman or
something like that) will eat the aip, if they are hungry, but if
suitable feed is found it is unlikely it will touch it. Copperbanded
butterflys eat it but then yu have another added fish to the bio load
to contend with....

Personally I like aip, and have a 0 gal tanbk setup with nothing but
all the undesireable types normally removed from an aquarium and
flushed or destroyed. Its amaziing and is just as interesting to look
at as a fully stocked reef tank is.......Aip that I have is beautiful,
easy to keep, and its also in various colors. I especially like the
extremely brilliant florescent yellow / green aip....Its just as
pretty as any high end anenome you r going to buy. And to tell the
truth, having it propagate and grow rampantly in this tank has not
been any kind of problem.........

JOes juice is high priced IMHO, but it works, but so does lemon juice,
or kalkwasser which is a lot cheaper.

On Thu, 02 Mar 2006 03:11:52 -0600, Martin
wrote:
Theres a product I use called Joe's Juice which I have used and it
does
work ! Its also supposed to be reef safe and I've never had any
trouble
with it. You don't need to inject, you just dribble the stuff over it
to
eat and they just dissapear. Great stuff.



"Billy" wrote in
news46dnRGmfvdlCJvZnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@comcast. com:

I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options
as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well
as
that section of live rock.

b


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....

The majority of my aipstasia that I place in my "Undesireables " tank
are what I spot on frags of corals and LR that I buy. I take note as
to where its located, and make it a point to frag off that portion of
the rubble on the coral or the LR. Thats what I place in my tank, and
9 out of 0 times the aip will then move off that piece of rubble or
frag and move elsewhere. I really doubt there is a way to remove
without killing or spreading aipstasia, or there would be no need for
Joes Juice and other methods. Just yesterday I bought a really neat
flat LV with a total of 6 shrooms on it (Ricordea yumas) and one warty
shroom. The rock was too large for my tanks space and I always
remove as much of the oroignal LR as possible so I can place things
where I want. This piece of LR had a super nice yellow green aipstasis
on it approximately 2" or better, so now after cutting LR into smaller
pieces I now have that aip relocated to the undesireables tank.


I bought the rock mainly for the warty mushroom and the aip, not the
other yumas, and this morning I woke up to a missing warty
shroom.....and we have looked all over the tank it was in and its
nowehre to be found.......real bummer. And the Aipstasia was glowing
in full color under the UV /Moon lights and looking great.

On Thu, 02 Mar 2006 17:34:27 GMT, "volux"
wrote:
Roy, just how are u gettin them safely off the rock into ur Aip tank?

Do you have any pics of this tank - i would love to see it


"Roy" wrote in message
.. .
YOu can get the same results with lemon juice, or if your paranoid
about injecting the stalk with lemon juice (all it takes is a tiny
drop) so ph etc is not affected. Use a syringe of kalkwasser, and just
squirt the aipstasia with it, no need to inject....I have used lemon
juice with excellent results. Unless you have a true peppermint shrimp
its not likely that the shrimp will eat it. Peppermints (wunderman or
something like that) will eat the aip, if they are hungry, but if
suitable feed is found it is unlikely it will touch it. Copperbanded
butterflys eat it but then yu have another added fish to the bio load
to contend with....

Personally I like aip, and have a 0 gal tanbk setup with nothing but
all the undesireable types normally removed from an aquarium and
flushed or destroyed. Its amaziing and is just as interesting to look
at as a fully stocked reef tank is.......Aip that I have is beautiful,
easy to keep, and its also in various colors. I especially like the
extremely brilliant florescent yellow / green aip....Its just as
pretty as any high end anenome you r going to buy. And to tell the
truth, having it propagate and grow rampantly in this tank has not
been any kind of problem.........

JOes juice is high priced IMHO, but it works, but so does lemon juice,
or kalkwasser which is a lot cheaper.

On Thu, 02 Mar 2006 03:11:52 -0600, Martin
wrote:
Theres a product I use called Joe's Juice which I have used and it
does
work ! Its also supposed to be reef safe and I've never had any
trouble
with it. You don't need to inject, you just dribble the stuff over it
to
eat and they just dissapear. Great stuff.



"Billy" wrote in
news46dnRGmfvdlCJvZnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@comcast. com:

I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options
as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well
as
that section of live rock.

b


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....

the problem is not the lemon juice, its injecting teh aptasia, this method
is a big hassle


"Roy" wrote in message
...
YOu can get the same results with lemon juice, or if your paranoid
about injecting the stalk with lemon juice (all it takes is a tiny
drop) so ph etc is not affected. Use a syringe of kalkwasser, and just
squirt the aipstasia with it, no need to inject....I have used lemon
juice with excellent results. Unless you have a true peppermint shrimp
its not likely that the shrimp will eat it. Peppermints (wunderman or
something like that) will eat the aip, if they are hungry, but if
suitable feed is found it is unlikely it will touch it. Copperbanded
butterflys eat it but then yu have another added fish to the bio load
to contend with....

Personally I like aip, and have a 0 gal tanbk setup with nothing but
all the undesireable types normally removed from an aquarium and
flushed or destroyed. Its amaziing and is just as interesting to look
at as a fully stocked reef tank is.......Aip that I have is beautiful,
easy to keep, and its also in various colors. I especially like the
extremely brilliant florescent yellow / green aip....Its just as
pretty as any high end anenome you r going to buy. And to tell the
truth, having it propagate and grow rampantly in this tank has not
been any kind of problem.........

JOes juice is high priced IMHO, but it works, but so does lemon juice,
or kalkwasser which is a lot cheaper.

On Thu, 02 Mar 2006 03:11:52 -0600, Martin
wrote:
Theres a product I use called Joe's Juice which I have used and it does
work ! Its also supposed to be reef safe and I've never had any
trouble
with it. You don't need to inject, you just dribble the stuff over it
to
eat and they just dissapear. Great stuff.



"Billy" wrote in
news46dnRGmfvdlCJvZnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@comcast .com:

I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well as
that section of live rock.

b


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....

Ya just have to be pretty quick to jab that joker with a nice 28 ga
insulin needle / syringe ;-)

Actually if you can see the hole it retracts back into on a live rock
its easy to stick it in the hole and get the aip. In a sand bed they
dissapear and leave no hole, but thats when I use a table spoon and
slip it under them and lift them out, or a snall grate type picker
upper made by Thomas Ind which has interchangeable heads for various
tank tasks, One item I use is the grate type thingie .,sort of like a
kitty litter box scooper to allow small stuff to fall back in the box
and removes the clumps........
I personally try to frag em out of the live rock and lift em out of a
sand bed, and relocate to my Undesireables Tank....
On Fri, 10 Mar 2006 18:27:28 GMT, "wolf" "
wrote:
the problem is not the lemon juice, its injecting teh aptasia, this method
is a big hassle


"Roy" wrote in message
.. .
YOu can get the same results with lemon juice, or if your paranoid
about injecting the stalk with lemon juice (all it takes is a tiny
drop) so ph etc is not affected. Use a syringe of kalkwasser, and just
squirt the aipstasia with it, no need to inject....I have used lemon
juice with excellent results. Unless you have a true peppermint shrimp
its not likely that the shrimp will eat it. Peppermints (wunderman or
something like that) will eat the aip, if they are hungry, but if
suitable feed is found it is unlikely it will touch it. Copperbanded
butterflys eat it but then yu have another added fish to the bio load
to contend with....

Personally I like aip, and have a 0 gal tanbk setup with nothing but
all the undesireable types normally removed from an aquarium and
flushed or destroyed. Its amaziing and is just as interesting to look
at as a fully stocked reef tank is.......Aip that I have is beautiful,
easy to keep, and its also in various colors. I especially like the
extremely brilliant florescent yellow / green aip....Its just as
pretty as any high end anenome you r going to buy. And to tell the
truth, having it propagate and grow rampantly in this tank has not
been any kind of problem.........

JOes juice is high priced IMHO, but it works, but so does lemon juice,
or kalkwasser which is a lot cheaper.

On Thu, 02 Mar 2006 03:11:52 -0600, Martin
wrote:
Theres a product I use called Joe's Juice which I have used and it does
work ! Its also supposed to be reef safe and I've never had any
trouble
with it. You don't need to inject, you just dribble the stuff over it
to
eat and they just dissapear. Great stuff.



"Billy" wrote in
news46dnRGmfvdlCJvZnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@com cast.com:

I squirted them with very hot water. I tried several other options as
well. You must be very careful with this method, as any other
critters close to the point of application will be killed, as well as
that section of live rock.

b


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....


--
\\\|///
( @ @ )
-----------oOOo(_)oOOo---------------


oooO
---------( )----Oooo----------------
\ ( ( )
\_) ) /
(_/
The original frugal ponder ! Koi-ahoi mates....

MarkW wrote:

Any suggestions on how I can solve this problem?

There's a nudibranch that eats only Aptasia. I don't remember the name, but you
can Google for it.

George Patterson
Coffee is only a way of stealing time that should by rights belong to
your slightly older self.