If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
I posted awhile back about getting a code for a passanger side
catalytic converter code. P030 I think??? It was something about being below efficiency or somethign like that. I replaced that o2 sensor after the cat and cleared the code but it came back again. This truck has 322,000 on it and dont want to spend too much. I did feel exhaust leak from wehre the exhaust mannifold meets the exhaust pipe at the collector but I assume this would not be the cause becasue this is before all the 02 sensors anyway. Well, I got to thinking, could I just move the after cat 02 sensor on that side to the other side exhaust pipe? In essense I would have 2 02 sensors in that side, then I could just remove the bad catalytic converter and replace with a straight pipe? The other option is an autozone "generic" cat for 75 bucks but someone on here said they were made out of cheap material and I am afraid of going through all that and the light still staying on. Appreciate any advice. |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
stryped > wrote:
>I posted awhile back about getting a code for a passanger side >catalytic converter code. P030 I think??? It was something about being >below efficiency or somethign like that. I replaced that o2 sensor >after the cat and cleared the code but it came back again. This truck >has 322,000 on it and dont want to spend too much. I did feel exhaust >leak from wehre the exhaust mannifold meets the exhaust pipe at the >collector but I assume this would not be the cause becasue this is >before all the 02 sensors anyway. Sure, why do actual diagnosis? Why not just swap things out at random and hope that fixes it? If you don't want to spend too much, though, why are you swapping things out before determining they are bad? >Well, I got to thinking, could I just move the after cat 02 sensor on >that side to the other side exhaust pipe? In essense I would have 2 02 >sensors in that side, then I could just remove the bad catalytic >converter and replace with a straight pipe? Maybe, maybe not. Since you haven't determined the problem yet, that would not seem like a good idea. >The other option is an autozone "generic" cat for 75 bucks but someone >on here said they were made out of cheap material and I am afraid of >going through all that and the light still staying on. > >Appreciate any advice. Why not actually perform the three tests that I suggested originally and then you'll know where the problem is? Alternately you can just go swapping things out randomly. Why not put a new transmission in? It won't hurt anything, only cost you a fortune... --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
On May 10, 10:05*am, (Scott Dorsey) wrote:
> stryped > wrote: > >I posted awhile back about getting a code for a passanger side > >catalytic converter code. P030 I think??? It was something about being > >below efficiency or somethign like that. I replaced that o2 sensor > >after the cat and cleared the code but it came back again. This truck > >has 322,000 on it and dont want to spend too much. I did feel exhaust > >leak from wehre the exhaust mannifold meets the exhaust pipe at the > >collector but I assume this would not be the cause becasue this is > >before all the 02 sensors anyway. > > Sure, why do actual diagnosis? *Why not just swap things out at random > and hope that fixes it? > > If you don't want to spend too much, though, why are you swapping things > out before determining they are bad? > > >Well, I got to thinking, could I just move the after cat 02 sensor on > >that side to the other side exhaust pipe? In essense I would have 2 02 > >sensors in that side, then I could just remove the bad catalytic > >converter and replace with a straight pipe? > > Maybe, maybe not. *Since you haven't determined the problem yet, that > would not seem like a good idea. > > >The other option is an autozone "generic" cat for 75 bucks but someone > >on here said they were made out of cheap material and I am afraid of > >going through all that and the light still staying on. > > >Appreciate any advice. > > Why not actually perform the three tests that I suggested originally and > then you'll know where the problem is? > > Alternately you can just go swapping things out randomly. *Why not put a > new transmission in? *It won't hurt anything, only cost you a fortune.... > --scott > -- > "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." I put the o2 sensor in becasue I purchased one last year for a code that came up for it. (I forget the code). Before I could put it in the check engine light went off and never came back on. So the part I purchased sat on the shelf. So I had it anyway and thought it was worth a try. I am assuming the only thing left is the cat. There is no exhaust leak between the two 02 sensors. There is one at the collector it sounds like but this is before any sensor. I know I need to fix that but I really feel it is the cat causing this code. I dont want to spend 400 bucks or more for the factory cat since the truck has 322,000 on it but I would like to eliminate the light coming on. My thinking is (maybe I am wrong) but when the light is on it reverts to closed loop mode and therefore would effect my gas mileage. I already spent 218 bucks for a new ignition module, spark plugs, and rotor/cap. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
"stryped" > wrote in message ... On May 10, 10:05 am, (Scott Dorsey) wrote: > stryped > wrote: > >I posted awhile back about getting a code for a passanger side > >catalytic converter code. P030 I think??? It was something about being > >below efficiency or somethign like that. I replaced that o2 sensor > >after the cat and cleared the code but it came back again. This truck > >has 322,000 on it and dont want to spend too much. I did feel exhaust > >leak from wehre the exhaust mannifold meets the exhaust pipe at the > >collector but I assume this would not be the cause becasue this is > >before all the 02 sensors anyway. > > Sure, why do actual diagnosis? Why not just swap things out at random > and hope that fixes it? > > If you don't want to spend too much, though, why are you swapping things > out before determining they are bad? > > >Well, I got to thinking, could I just move the after cat 02 sensor on > >that side to the other side exhaust pipe? In essense I would have 2 02 > >sensors in that side, then I could just remove the bad catalytic > >converter and replace with a straight pipe? > > Maybe, maybe not. Since you haven't determined the problem yet, that > would not seem like a good idea. > > >The other option is an autozone "generic" cat for 75 bucks but someone > >on here said they were made out of cheap material and I am afraid of > >going through all that and the light still staying on. > > >Appreciate any advice. > > Why not actually perform the three tests that I suggested originally and > then you'll know where the problem is? > > Alternately you can just go swapping things out randomly. Why not put a > new transmission in? It won't hurt anything, only cost you a fortune... > --scott > -- > "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." I put the o2 sensor in becasue I purchased one last year for a code that came up for it. (I forget the code). Before I could put it in the check engine light went off and never came back on. So the part I purchased sat on the shelf. So I had it anyway and thought it was worth a try. I am assuming the only thing left is the cat. There is no exhaust leak between the two 02 sensors. There is one at the collector it sounds like but this is before any sensor. I know I need to fix that but I really feel it is the cat causing this code. I dont want to spend 400 bucks or more for the factory cat since the truck has 322,000 on it but I would like to eliminate the light coming on. My thinking is (maybe I am wrong) but when the light is on it reverts to closed loop mode and therefore would effect my gas mileage. I already spent 218 bucks for a new ignition module, spark plugs, and rotor/cap. ******* As Scott mentioned, a little time diagnosing is a lot more successful and a lot less costly than just guessing what might be wrong. If you didnt see or didnt understand what he suggested you do, just ask him. He is a nice fellow and is always helpful on here. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
stryped > wrote:
>I put the o2 sensor in becasue I purchased one last year for a code >that came up for it. (I forget the code). Before I could put it in the >check engine light went off and never came back on. So the part I >purchased sat on the shelf. So I had it anyway and thought it was >worth a try. I am assuming the only thing left is the cat. There is no >exhaust leak between the two 02 sensors. There is one at the collector >it sounds like but this is before any sensor. I know I need to fix >that but I really feel it is the cat causing this code. Fix it. If you're leaking before or after, the pressure in the cat can be too low and then it won't work properly and you'll get the error. Check the whole exhaust system for leaks. >I dont want to >spend 400 bucks or more for the factory cat since the truck has >322,000 on it but I would like to eliminate the light coming on. My >thinking is (maybe I am wrong) but when the light is on it reverts to >closed loop mode and therefore would effect my gas mileage. You are wrong. This is a warning message and has nothing to do with the actual operation. The output of the downstream sensor is only to tell you the emission control system isn't working right, it does not provide any feedback to the engine control algorithm. The operation of the vehicle is not affected in any way. >I already spent 218 bucks for a new ignition module, spark plugs, and >rotor/cap. This is how cars are, you have ongoing maintenance. Either you want the light to go out enough to fix the problem properly, or you can live with the light being on. --scott -- "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
stryped wrote:
> > On May 10, 10:05 am, (Scott Dorsey) wrote: > > stryped > wrote: > > >I posted awhile back about getting a code for a passanger side > > >catalytic converter code. P030 I think??? It was something about being > > >below efficiency or somethign like that. I replaced that o2 sensor > > >after the cat and cleared the code but it came back again. This truck > > >has 322,000 on it and dont want to spend too much. I did feel exhaust > > >leak from wehre the exhaust mannifold meets the exhaust pipe at the > > >collector but I assume this would not be the cause becasue this is > > >before all the 02 sensors anyway. > > > > Sure, why do actual diagnosis? Why not just swap things out at random > > and hope that fixes it? > > > > If you don't want to spend too much, though, why are you swapping things > > out before determining they are bad? > > > > >Well, I got to thinking, could I just move the after cat 02 sensor on > > >that side to the other side exhaust pipe? In essense I would have 2 02 > > >sensors in that side, then I could just remove the bad catalytic > > >converter and replace with a straight pipe? > > > > Maybe, maybe not. Since you haven't determined the problem yet, that > > would not seem like a good idea. > > > > >The other option is an autozone "generic" cat for 75 bucks but someone > > >on here said they were made out of cheap material and I am afraid of > > >going through all that and the light still staying on. > > > > >Appreciate any advice. > > > > Why not actually perform the three tests that I suggested originally and > > then you'll know where the problem is? > > > > Alternately you can just go swapping things out randomly. Why not put a > > new transmission in? It won't hurt anything, only cost you a fortune... > > --scott > > -- > > "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." > > I put the o2 sensor in becasue I purchased one last year for a code > that came up for it. (I forget the code). Before I could put it in the > check engine light went off and never came back on. So the part I > purchased sat on the shelf. So I had it anyway and thought it was > worth a try. I am assuming the only thing left is the cat. There is no > exhaust leak between the two 02 sensors. The exhaust leak can still be the cause > There is one at the collector > it sounds like but this is before any sensor. I know I need to fix > that but I really feel it is the cat causing this code. I dont want to > spend 400 bucks or more for the factory cat since the truck has > 322,000 on it but I would like to eliminate the light coming on. My > thinking is (maybe I am wrong) but when the light is on it reverts to > closed loop mode and therefore would effect my gas mileage. no your thinking is wrong. The light comes on as a result of a diagnostic test that the engine control performs once every trip (if the trip is long enough). The test determines how fast the CAT can respond to quickly changing Air/Fuel mixture. A leak can mess up the test. Whether the test passes or fails doesn't affect the engine performance. The purpose of the test is to determine when the CAT is not working efficiently. The main danger of having the light on is you may miss other codes. -jim > > I already spent 218 bucks for a new ignition module, spark plugs, and > rotor/cap. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
On May 10, 2:50*pm, (Scott Dorsey) wrote:
> stryped > wrote: > >I put the o2 sensor in becasue I purchased one last year for a code > >that came up for it. (I forget the code). Before I could put it in the > >check engine light went off and never came back on. So the part I > >purchased sat on the shelf. So I had it anyway and thought it was > >worth a try. I am assuming the only thing left is the cat. There is no > >exhaust leak between the two 02 sensors. There is one at the collector > >it sounds like but this is before any sensor. I know I need to fix > >that but I really feel it is the cat causing this code. > > Fix it. *If you're leaking before or after, the pressure in the cat can be > too low and then it won't work properly and you'll get the error. *Check > the whole exhaust system for leaks. > > >I dont want to > >spend 400 bucks or more for the factory cat since the truck has > >322,000 on it but I would like to eliminate the light coming on. My > >thinking is (maybe I am wrong) but when the light is on it reverts to > >closed loop mode and therefore would effect my gas mileage. > > You are wrong. *This is a warning message and has nothing to do with the > actual operation. *The output of the downstream sensor is only to tell you > the emission control system isn't working right, it does not provide any > feedback to the engine control algorithm. > > The operation of the vehicle is not affected in any way. > > >I already spent 218 bucks for a new ignition module, spark plugs, and > >rotor/cap. > > This is how cars are, you have ongoing maintenance. *Either you want the > light to go out enough to fix the problem properly, or you can live with > the light being on. > --scott > -- > "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis." Ok. Is it hard to get the three botls off at the collect on a 322,000 mile engine? (I just dont want to break something off and create a bigger problem). Also, If I take the collector off and replace the gasket (I am assuming this is where the leak is coming from) and fixing the exhaust leak sdoes not fix the code, I will have to take the collector off again to replace the cat to prooerly weld a new one in there. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
stryped wrote:
> I posted awhile back about getting a code for a passanger side > catalytic converter code. P030 I think??? It was something about being > below efficiency or somethign like that. I replaced that o2 sensor > after the cat and cleared the code but it came back again. This truck > has 322,000 on it and dont want to spend too much. I did feel exhaust > leak from wehre the exhaust mannifold meets the exhaust pipe at the > collector but I assume this would not be the cause becasue this is > before all the 02 sensors anyway. Actually ANY leaks in the exhaust prior to the last sensor can cause codes. I have even seen cases where a high flow muffler caused a cat code. The reason is that the way the system tests the converter and sensors is actually simple. It cycles the fuel system from rich to lean very rapidly and looks at the voltages from the sensors to tell it if the system is responding properly. The leak will throw the system off and set a code. Another one that can drive you nuts is a vacuum leak around the manifold. The engine only sees a difference at the O2 sensor that it cannot account for and will set lean codes and cat codes. > > Well, I got to thinking, could I just move the after cat 02 sensor on > that side to the other side exhaust pipe? In essense I would have 2 02 > sensors in that side, then I could just remove the bad catalytic > converter and replace with a straight pipe? Sure if you don't mind failing inspection and facing a federal fine for tampering with the emissions controls. Removal of a cat is a VERY big NO NO.... > > The other option is an autozone "generic" cat for 75 bucks but someone > on here said they were made out of cheap material and I am afraid of > going through all that and the light still staying on. > Fix the exhaust leak and then use a good scan tool and watch the voltages from the O2 sensors while driving around. All it takes to set a code is a lazy sensor. Bad cat is also possible. 220 bucks for a new Y pipe and cat isn't bad. That is an Eastern Direct fit for a 305/350 application with single exhaust. If you have the dual converter/pipe system the unit is 264 bucks. -- Steve W. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
1996 Silverado cat converter
stryped > wrote in
: > There is no exhaust leak between the two 02 sensors. There is one at > the collector it sounds like but this is before any sensor. Do you have any idea how exhaust emission controls work? You've just given a gigantic clue as to your problem, if you only understood what you just said. -- Tegger |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Cat Converter Shield | help-slip-franklin | Jeep | 9 | October 7th 08 08:32 PM |
Bad Cat converter | Tube Audio[_2_] | Technology | 2 | February 26th 08 06:58 PM |
Cat converter | Mike | Corvette | 4 | June 6th 06 04:48 PM |
symptoms of a clogged cat converter | [email protected] | Honda | 3 | November 24th 05 12:33 AM |
76 Cars/What to do about cat converter? | Halterb | Antique cars | 0 | August 31st 03 12:08 PM |