turn off or not for winter

SkyCatcher wrote:

I seen conflicting info regarding what to do with your pump/filter in the
winter....

one source said to turn off the pump when the fish stop feeding and let
the water temp stratify thus keeping a 4oC layer (in U.K.) at the bottom

It really depends where you are. In much of the UK, your water would rarely
get much cooler than that anyway.

In most of Canada, it's not a good idea to run a pump in the winter unless
you keep both intake and outflow close to the surface.

Also, no waste from the fish to feeed the bateria in the filter so no
point!

Not much activity from the bacteria, either.

the other source said to leave them running all winter just to keep the
pond clean/clear & reduce spring clean-up.

Only if your pond doesn't freeze. Otherwise, keeping the pump off the
bottom, to allow warmer water to collect there, will also let the crud
collect there too, so you get no filtration benefit. In any case, you'd be
getting purely mechanical filtration - with no biological breakdown - so
your filter would need a good clean in spring.

What is the general concenus here??

You'll get individual opinions - you'll have to figure out the consensus
yourself :-)
--
derek