![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. I thought the betta would only be aggressive towards other bettas. They were doing fine for almost a month and then when I woke up this morning I noticed my goldfish had red spots on his body and my bettas fins had been nipped all over the place. It basically looks like the webbing is gone from the long fins and what is left are more like pink strands of fin. Can this heal? How can I tell if there is other damage? What should I do about my goldfish? So far I have put them in separate bowls, but I am pretty new to fish keeping and dont know how to help my betta, she looks worse off than the goldfish.
Help me! Cassie |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Cassie" wrote in message ... I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. ## I never trust bettas. They can turn on other fish in a heartbeat. All my bettas live alone. As for goldfish - the rule is 10 gallons per fish since they get quite large if healthy. They're big eaters and pass a lot of waste. A 2 gallon tank is only suitable for a few guppies or a betta. I thought the betta would only be aggressive towards other bettas. ## I have seen them turn aggressive against tankmates they'd been with for weeks, maybe months. They were doing fine for almost a month and then when I woke up this morning I noticed my goldfish had red spots on his body and my bettas fins had been nipped all over the place. It basically looks like the webbing is gone from the long fins and what is left are more like pink strands of fin. Can this heal? ## If he's healthy and the water is really clean. If infection sets in it can die. How can I tell if there is other damage? What should I do about my goldfish? ## Buy a tank large enough to keep goldfish. If you have 2 then get a 20 gallon tank, if 3 get a 30L tank and so on. So far I have put them in separate bowls, ## They will suffocate in bowls unless they have some type of filter and aeration. Please buy a tank for them or find them another home. but I am pretty new to fish keeping and dont know how to help my betta, she looks worse off than the goldfish. ## You can Google goldfish and bettas. There are thousands of webpages to learn their needs and how to best meet them. My Pond & Aquarium Pages: http://bellsouthpwp.net/s/h/shastadaisy ~~~ }((((o ~~~ }{{{{o ~~~ }(((((o |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Cassie wrote:
I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. I thought the betta would only be aggressive towards other bettas. They were doing fine for almost a month and then when I woke up this morning I noticed my goldfish had red spots on his body and my bettas fins had been nipped all over the place. It basically looks like the webbing is gone from the long fins and what is left are more like pink strands of fin. Can this heal? How can I tell if there is other damage? What should I do about my goldfish? So far I have put them in separate bowls, but I am pretty new to fish keeping and dont know how to help my betta, she looks worse off than the goldfish. Help me! Cassie Fins can heal as long as the flesh at the base of the fin is not hurt. There is not likely any internal damage to your fish and separating them was exactly the right thing to do. Both of your fish simply need very clean water and good food to heal. Clean water is a challenge in small bowls so you will need to do a lot of water changes and avoid leaving any uneaten food in the bottom. To help avoid finrot or fungus, you might want to use a mild antiseptic like Bettafix or Melafix for the next week. Also, add 1 tsp/gallon of dissolved aquarium salt, sea salt, or pickling salt to the bowls to help them recover. Keep an eye on the goldfish to be sure he's not gasping at the top of the water and has enough oxygen, and add an airstone if he has any trouble. Hope your fish make it OK. -- Elaine T __ http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__ rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256 Cassie wrote: ***Update*** Thanks for all the advice, I really appreciate you replying so quickly. My betta fish is doing much better. I was wondering if the betta also needs to bubbling air filter.. Obviously the goldfish did. i didnt know that. he had been fine for the past 3 weeks. When i came home from work, he was gasping for air, never had done it before. Before I had time to put in an air filter he died. I am still upset about it, but now I know. No more goldfish until I have room for @ least a 10 gallon tank.I bought some salt to put in the water to assist w/ the healing. Thanks again! I'm sorry to hear about your goldfish. Bettas breathe air and can live fine in perfectly still water. In fact, they prefer water without too much movement so they can maintain their bubblenests. I think two gallon tanks are perfect for bettas, although some people like to give a betta more room so it can swim around. - -- Elaine T __ http://eethomp.com/fish.html '__ rec.aquaria.* FAQ http://faq.thekrib.com PGP public key available at https://keyserver1.pgp.com/ -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: PGP Desktop 9.0.2 (Build 2424) - not licensed for commercial use: www.pgp.com iQEVAwUBQ3y/a6OlgZbhv3MBAQg2hAgAwJaIxi0EhL0sw4t1Oo8wXziMDq4i9X IP m38O8vpsnVllrRVeve/rqtuz0HnAuploiJtA0NuBX/y+94wTS64QbxrhOkiVAS+H k/JG6FDL7fzvfu9jL4tZpSYmo/kcNBouwZUXaHE6tya5MryEOHhYcXKyjkfaYm5H TR7b9gyzftCNVBLlenjOy7Z4OGYG6YJ/9tD57/Ymtvxfqiw1hf4xM9ChV7T75sfJ wkm5aM0xEm41ePMaXJAHEq0LdBefcK9FrUXinTzEWNpxK7jWT5 yhPIkz1lTXKFgM QAXXjF+RtdMwdbeguNj9lW13v/h0n+tqhDnm6dy5DldWxvNdpAMXWA== =1skz -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Koi-lo wrote: "Cassie" wrote in message ... I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. ## I never trust bettas. They can turn on other fish in a heartbeat. All my bettas live alone. As for goldfish - the rule is 10 gallons per fish since they get quite large if healthy. They're big eaters and pass a lot of waste. A 2 gallon tank is only suitable for a few guppies or a betta. I thought the betta would only be aggressive towards other bettas. ## I have seen them turn aggressive against tankmates they'd been with for weeks, maybe months. They were doing fine for almost a month and then when I woke up this morning I noticed my goldfish had red spots on his body and my bettas fins had been nipped all over the place. It basically looks like the webbing is gone from the long fins and what is left are more like pink strands of fin. Can this heal? ## If he's healthy and the water is really clean. If infection sets in it can die. How can I tell if there is other damage? What should I do about my goldfish? ## Buy a tank large enough to keep goldfish. If you have 2 then get a 20 gallon tank, if 3 get a 30L tank and so on. So far I have put them in separate bowls, ## They will suffocate in bowls unless they have some type of filter and aeration. Please buy a tank for them or find them another home. but I am pretty new to fish keeping and dont know how to help my betta, she looks worse off than the goldfish. ## You can Google goldfish and bettas. There are thousands of webpages to learn their needs and how to best meet them. My Pond & Aquarium Pages: http://bellsouthpwp.net/s/h/shastadaisy ~~~ }((((o ~~~ }{{{{o ~~~ }(((((o Koi-lo wrote: ## I never trust bettas. They can turn on other fish in a heartbeat. All my bettas live alone. You simply do not understand Bettas. Bettas don't just "turn" on tank mates. You simply didn't understand the "why". (back ground on myself....I have been a Betta fancier for nearly 28 yrs and have bred them for many of those years) Each Betta has an individual personality. These fish are aware of their surroundings too. They really do know who their keeper is. That wiggle dance they do every time you walk into the room isn't begging for food all the time. They're also trying to get your attention. Bettas are also socialble fish. They don't want to be solitary. Bettas have a hierarchy and right there that shows you that these fish are not solitary by nature. Rarely you will find an overly aggressvie Betta that must be kept isolated, but the majority are fine in a community tank with suitable tank mates for the Betta, as they are usually the ones getting nipped, not the other way around. Many times a male that is put into a community tank may huff and puff at first, but usually they calm down right away as soon as they realize these other fish aren't going to harm them. Many times Bettas that are kept solitary become listless and bored. Some even go into depression without a flare buddy or tank mates. I hope you are keeping your solitary males next to each other so that they can flare with each other. Another common myth is that they will be stressed too much and die if housed next to other males permantly. It just isn't so. They actually need the exercise and stimulation. The largest myth out there regarding Bettas is that they *prefer* small tanks without filtration. Absolutely untrue. Just because they can survive in a small, unfiltered tank doesn't mean that they enjoy or prefer it, and don't succumb to the affects of dirty water like regular fish do. Bettas, like every fish in the world, benefit from filtration. In smaller tanks (minimum 1gal) their water should be changed 100% 1-2 times weekly in order for them to not suffer from high nitrite/nitrate and ammonia levels, just like other fish. Because Bettas can breathe surface air with their labyrinth organ people mistakingly believe that this means they prefer to live in small spaces and don't suffer the ill affects of high ammonia or nirtite/nitrates levels. I'll never understand why folks think this way. The myth about them prefering small bowls because they live in small mud puddles in the wild makes me want to choke the person saying it. Folks don't undertsand that Rice paddy fileds are NOT small mud puddles. They're usually about 18" deep and the size of a lake or other larger body of water. These are fed fresh water constantly, not stagnant mud puddles like some would have you beleive. Nature gave them a labyrinth organ so that they could *survive* the dry seasons. This is where the myth of them prefering it comes into play. They can *survive* in tiny, shallow puddles until the rains come again. Another myth is that the males fight to the death. In the wild, they hardly ever rip each other to shreds. They posture, flare, nip and chase. The loser simply swims away. In a tank they have no place to go. The loser isn't "swimming away" so the winner continues and then chunks are taken out of the fins, as well as the body. The loser usually dies from it's injuries, not that they fought to the death. Bettas definately need a certain amount of territory for them selves. If a tank isn't large enough to house either a male or female Betta with other tank mates than it feels threatened and will pursue the "intruder". Sometimes the tank simply doesn't have enough decorations or plants to establish proper territories, and hence the Betta feels threatented and goes after the tank mate. So please, Koi-Lo, research a bit more about Bettas. They'll be better for it, and you can also then give out proper advice about them as well. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Cassie wrote: I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. I thought the betta would only be aggressive towards other bettas. They were doing fine for almost a month and then when I woke up this morning I noticed my goldfish had red spots on his body and my bettas fins had been nipped all over the place. It basically looks like the webbing is gone from the long fins and what is left are more like pink strands of fin. Can this heal? How can I tell if there is other damage? What should I do about my goldfish? So far I have put them in separate bowls, but I am pretty new to fish keeping and dont know how to help my betta, she looks worse off than the goldfish. Help me! Cassie -- Cassie Cassie wrote: I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. You should never house Goldfish with tropical fish. Bascially, only Goldfish can be kept with Goldfish. DoJo loaches are about the only other tank mates that can go with them other than other Goldies. Bettas (pronounced "bet-uh") need to be kept in tanks a minimum of a gallon, but need heated water, so that's very hard to do in such a small tank. They also should have filtration as well. Unless you plan on changing 100% of the water weekl, then use a filter. Bettas only prefer still waters when spawning. There's too much false information out there when it comes to Bettas. Sadly, most of the false info you'll hear will be from the pet shops! Goldfish, depending in the type need large, filtered tanks. The Oranda type Goldies that have stocky, fat bodies really need minimum of 10-15 gallons per fish and 15-20 gallons per Goldie when it's the common or Comet type, as they grow much longer (some up to 16" long). Koi have no business in home aquariums and should only be kept in large ponds. They simply grow much too large for the average home aquarium. In either case, Goldies require extra filtration as they put out a great deal more waste than the average fish. They also should have bumped up water changes as well. A 2 gallon tank is never a good thing for a Goldfish, unless it's filtered and the fish is an inch long baby. Goldies also are long lived fish. Their lifespan is about 20 yrs. Bettas, average about 2-4 yrs. However, if kept under good conditions they can live over 5. Of course genetics play a part in that as well. Sorry to hear that your Goldie didn't make it. Now, how is the Betta doing? Keep his water clean, and heated to 78-80*f, and fed well and he should heal quickly. Bettas, by nature, heal very quickly....as long as they have clean water and are kept warm. Bettas in dirty, colder water are suceptible to diseases such Fin Rot and Fungus when they have been damaged. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Tynk wrote:
Koi-lo wrote: "Cassie" wrote in message . .. I had a betta fish who was healthy and happy when I (stupidly) decided that it would be ok to keep it together with a new goldfish in a two gallon tank. ## I never trust bettas. They can turn on other fish in a heartbeat. All my bettas live alone. As for goldfish - the rule is 10 gallons per fish since they get quite large if healthy. They're big eaters and pass a lot of waste. A 2 gallon tank is only suitable for a few guppies or a betta. I thought the betta would only be aggressive towards other bettas. ## I have seen them turn aggressive against tankmates they'd been with for weeks, maybe months. They were doing fine for almost a month and then when I woke up this morning I noticed my goldfish had red spots on his body and my bettas fins had been nipped all over the place. It basically looks like the webbing is gone from the long fins and what is left are more like pink strands of fin. Can this heal? ## If he's healthy and the water is really clean. If infection sets in it can die. How can I tell if there is other damage? What should I do about my goldfish? ## Buy a tank large enough to keep goldfish. If you have 2 then get a 20 gallon tank, if 3 get a 30L tank and so on. So far I have put them in separate bowls, ## They will suffocate in bowls unless they have some type of filter and aeration. Please buy a tank for them or find them another home. but I am pretty new to fish keeping and dont know how to help my betta, she looks worse off than the goldfish. ## You can Google goldfish and bettas. There are thousands of webpages to learn their needs and how to best meet them. My Pond & Aquarium Pages: http://bellsouthpwp.net/s/h/shastadaisy ~~~ }((((o ~~~ }{{{{o ~~~ }(((((o Koi-lo wrote: ## I never trust bettas. They can turn on other fish in a heartbeat. All my bettas live alone. You simply do not understand Bettas. Bettas don't just "turn" on tank mates. You simply didn't understand the "why". (back ground on myself....I have been a Betta fancier for nearly 28 yrs and have bred them for many of those years) Each Betta has an individual personality. These fish are aware of their surroundings too. They really do know who their keeper is. That wiggle dance they do every time you walk into the room isn't begging for food all the time. They're also trying to get your attention. Bettas are also socialble fish. They don't want to be solitary. Bettas have a hierarchy and right there that shows you that these fish are not solitary by nature. Rarely you will find an overly aggressvie Betta that must be kept isolated, but the majority are fine in a community tank with suitable tank mates for the Betta, as they are usually the ones getting nipped, not the other way around. Many times a male that is put into a community tank may huff and puff at first, but usually they calm down right away as soon as they realize these other fish aren't going to harm them. Many times Bettas that are kept solitary become listless and bored. Some even go into depression without a flare buddy or tank mates. I hope you are keeping your solitary males next to each other so that they can flare with each other. Another common myth is that they will be stressed too much and die if housed next to other males permantly. It just isn't so. They actually need the exercise and stimulation. The largest myth out there regarding Bettas is that they *prefer* small tanks without filtration. Absolutely untrue. Just because they can survive in a small, unfiltered tank doesn't mean that they enjoy or prefer it, and don't succumb to the affects of dirty water like regular fish do. Bettas, like every fish in the world, benefit from filtration. In smaller tanks (minimum 1gal) their water should be changed 100% 1-2 times weekly in order for them to not suffer from high nitrite/nitrate and ammonia levels, just like other fish. Because Bettas can breathe surface air with their labyrinth organ people mistakingly believe that this means they prefer to live in small spaces and don't suffer the ill affects of high ammonia or nirtite/nitrates levels. I'll never understand why folks think this way. The myth about them prefering small bowls because they live in small mud puddles in the wild makes me want to choke the person saying it. Folks don't undertsand that Rice paddy fileds are NOT small mud puddles. They're usually about 18" deep and the size of a lake or other larger body of water. These are fed fresh water constantly, not stagnant mud puddles like some would have you beleive. Nature gave them a labyrinth organ so that they could *survive* the dry seasons. This is where the myth of them prefering it comes into play. They can *survive* in tiny, shallow puddles until the rains come again. Another myth is that the males fight to the death. In the wild, they hardly ever rip each other to shreds. They posture, flare, nip and chase. The loser simply swims away. In a tank they have no place to go. The loser isn't "swimming away" so the winner continues and then chunks are taken out of the fins, as well as the body. The loser usually dies from it's injuries, not that they fought to the death. Bettas definately need a certain amount of territory for them selves. If a tank isn't large enough to house either a male or female Betta with other tank mates than it feels threatened and will pursue the "intruder". Sometimes the tank simply doesn't have enough decorations or plants to establish proper territories, and hence the Betta feels threatented and goes after the tank mate. So please, Koi-Lo, research a bit more about Bettas. They'll be better for it, and you can also then give out proper advice about them as well. Hmmmm, you've given me an idea....I'd never thought of putting the two betta tanks together - one of them (Bob's tank) is in quite a dark area so I struggle to keep it pretty for him and was going to be moving it as soon as I thought of a good location...if he moved next to Boris the tank would get more light - and I might get some workspace back in the kitchen :-) Thanks Gill |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Tynk" wrote in message ups.com... Koi-lo wrote: ## I never trust bettas. They can turn on other fish in a heartbeat. All my bettas live alone. ============================ You simply do not understand Bettas. Bettas don't just "turn" on tank mates. You simply didn't understand the "why". (back ground on myself....I have been a Betta fancier for nearly 28 yrs and have bred them for many of those years) Each Betta has an individual personality. These fish are aware of their surroundings too. They really do know who their keeper is. That wiggle dance they do every time you walk into the room isn't begging for food all the time. They're also trying to get your attention. Bettas are also socialble fish. They don't want to be solitary. Bettas have a hierarchy and right there that shows you that these fish are not solitary by nature. Rarely you will find an overly aggressvie Betta that must be kept isolated, but the majority are fine in a community tank with suitable tank mates for the Betta, as they are usually the ones getting nipped, not the other way around. Many times a male that is put into a community tank may huff and puff at first, but usually they calm down right away as soon as they realize these other fish aren't going to harm them. ## I agree with most of this but I have seen bettas I raised myself go very well in a community tank, then for no good reason we could ever see - suddenly viciously rip another fishes tail or other fins. We didn't just suspect them of doing it, we saw them do it. :-( Many times Bettas that are kept solitary become listless and bored. Some even go into depression without a flare buddy or tank mates. I hope you are keeping your solitary males next to each other so that they can flare with each other. ## I agree with this as well. I keep mine next to each other on a windowsill. They seem to enjoy watching what's going on outside, each other and what we're doing. :-) Another common myth is that they will be stressed too much and die if housed next to other males permantly. It just isn't so. They actually need the exercise and stimulation. The largest myth out there regarding Bettas is that they *prefer* small tanks without filtration. Absolutely untrue. ## Agreed! Each of mine has a bowl or small tank complete with gravel and at least one live plant. They live up to 4 years. I haven't bred them here because I'd have to do too much work on our hard alkaline water. In NYC it was a softer acid water and they'd breed like crazy. Just because they can survive in a small, unfiltered tank doesn't mean that they enjoy or prefer it, and don't succumb to the affects of dirty water like regular fish do. Bettas, like every fish in the world, benefit from filtration. In smaller tanks (minimum 1gal) their water should be changed 100% 1-2 times weekly in order for them to not suffer from high nitrite/nitrate and ammonia levels, just like other fish. ## You can help Prevent that with a small amount of gravel and one floating water lettuce. WL doesn't get large in bowls and tanks but sure sucks up the phosphates and nitrates. Because Bettas can breathe surface air with their labyrinth organ people mistakingly believe that this means they prefer to live in small spaces and don't suffer the ill affects of high ammonia or nirtite/nitrates levels. I'll never understand why folks think this way. ## They simply don't know any better. Sometimes the tank simply doesn't have enough decorations or plants to establish proper territories, and hence the Betta feels threatented and goes after the tank mate. ## All my tanks are full of plants and natural rocks. Nothing artificial. Why some of these males take exception to tankmates they've been with and start shredding their fins we'll never know for sure. I simply removed them to gallon pickle jars when caught in the act. So please, Koi-Lo, research a bit more about Bettas. They'll be better for it, and you can also then give out proper advice about them as well. ## I stand by what I said since I caught them in the act. There was no reason that we could see for them to suddenly come up next to another fish and quickly and viciously rip it's fins..... no bubble nests were present. The other fish were no threat to them in any way. The only other explanation was they may have been a particularly aggressive strain of bettas. To this day I don't keep them in community tanks. If a betta is added to a community and suddenly you start seeing ripped fins - he's the one to watch . :-) And yes, I will always keep bettas as I love them to death. I just bought a female for $3.49 because of her beauty and perfection. Who knows,... maybe I will try breeding them in our water. -- Koi-Lo.... frugal ponding since 1995... My Pond & Aquarium Pages: http://bellsouthpwp.net/s/h/shastadaisy ~~~ }((((o ~~~ }{{{{o ~~~ }(((((o |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Gill Passman" wrote in message .. . Hmmmm, you've given me an idea....I'd never thought of putting the two betta tanks together - one of them (Bob's tank) is in quite a dark area so I struggle to keep it pretty for him and was going to be moving it as soon as I thought of a good location...if he moved next to Boris the tank would get more light - and I might get some workspace back in the kitchen :-) ======================= Most of my bettas are on my sunny kitchen windowsill. They're next to each other in an assortment of bowls with gravel and a water lettuce in each. The window is a double-pane but on really cold nights I move them to the counter. Two are in my sunroom. One beauty is in a filtered 2 gallon tank and an aged no longer attractive male is in a gallon pickle jar amid the tropical houseplants. You can say he's in retirement. -- Koi-Lo.... frugal ponding since 1995... My Pond & Aquarium Pages: http://bellsouthpwp.net/s/h/shastadaisy ~~~ }((((o ~~~ }{{{{o ~~~ }(((((o |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Hurt Betta and Goldfish , Help please!!! | Cassie | General | 2 | March 16th 06 07:19 PM |
Goldfish and siamese fighting fish? | Hardhat | Goldfish | 8 | January 7th 05 07:04 PM |
NYT Mag article about goldfish vets | Gunther | Goldfish | 1 | May 3rd 04 12:03 PM |
Female Betta with missing ventral fin | Lady Samsara | General | 16 | March 1st 04 05:36 PM |
Now my betta has fin rot... | Mike | General | 6 | December 17th 03 05:51 PM |